Skip to main content

Why Innovation Doesn’t Last

Schools talk a lot about innovation. New programs, new strategies, new initiatives. But one thing I keep wondering is how much of that innovation actually lasts.

Whenever something new comes down from the district, veteran teachers often say the same thing: “We tried that before.” Education has a habit of swinging back and forth between ideas. Teachers are asked to learn something new, invest time in understanding it, and adjust their practice — only for it to disappear a few years later.

I’ve seen this happen with several initiatives. For example, we were encouraged to adopt new ways of communicating student learning. Traditional report cards were supposed to shift toward more authentic reporting where teachers had flexibility in when and how they shared progress with families. Over time, though, that flexibility slowly disappeared. Eventually the system moved back toward a familiar structure of three reporting periods, goals, and core competencies.

Technology tools show a similar pattern. We were asked to adopt FreshGrade, then FreshGrade 2.0, then Seesaw. Now, after a few years, that system is also being replaced. Each change requires teachers to learn a new platform, rebuild routines, and adapt communication with families. By the time teachers feel comfortable with the system, it often changes again.

Some of the course readings helped me think about why this happens. Madden (2015) suggests that meaningful change in education requires deeper shifts in how learning is structured, not just new initiatives layered onto existing systems.

Maybe real innovation isn’t about constantly introducing something new. Maybe it’s about giving teachers the time, resources, and stability needed to make meaningful ideas last. Veteran teachers aren't stubborn; they are just tired of "innovations" never lasting.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Why Role Reversals Still Upset the Internet

"It's just a commercial. It's just a mermaid. It's just a superhero." And yet, every time those roles are reversed—online outrage flares up. Why? By: Shannon A Disorienting Photo Series A captivating photo series published in O, The Oprah Magazine flipped familiar situations with a racial spin: a white child surrounded by Black dolls, a white servant with a Black housewife, and white salon techs serving Asian customers. Scenes meant to question the "norm". They expose how deeply we internalize who belongs where in society. A white girl looks at a row of dolls, all of whom have dark skin tones, challenging toy aisle norms. Image: Chris Buck/O, the Oprah Magazine Art? Or A Deeper Issue But this isn’t just about photography. Projects like this are not new and have always prompted broader reflections, one on a growing trend across media of role reversals in race, gender, and power. From TikTok trends to pop music, these inversions are everywhere, and almos...
Read more

Reflection as a Way of Life- Final

Looking back at my work throughout PME 811, I believe my assignments demonstrate thoughtful engagement with both the course readings and my own professional experience as a teacher. Many of the concepts explored in this course—creativity, innovation, teaching, and learning—were ideas I had already considered in my practice. However, considering these ideas through readings, discussions, and written reflections helped me examine them more critically and connect them more clearly to broader educational systems. One of the biggest takeaways from this course is that innovation in education is often much more gradual and complex than it is presented in policy or professional development initiatives. Through my blog posts and assignments, I reflected on how educational systems frequently introduce new initiatives that promise improvement but do not always last long enough to create meaningful change. This idea became clearer through readings such as Cuban’s discussion of educational reform ...
Post a Comment
Read more